CN Mud Creek Bridge (Vinton)


Click the photo to view the full-size version

1/14
Date Taken:
Author:
Caption:

Name CN Mud Creek Bridge (Vinton)
Built By Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Northern Railway
Currently Owned By Canadian National Railway
Contractor Elmer J.C. Bealer of Cedar Valley, Iowa (Initial Construction)
Unknown (Encasement)
Length 92 Feet, 46 Foot Spans
Width 1 Track (36 Feet)
Height Above Ground 25 Feet (Estimated)
Superstructure Design Stone Arch (Concrete Encased)
Substructure Design Stone Masonry and Concrete
Date Built 1898, Encased c. 1940
Traffic Count 4 Trains/Day (Estimated)
Current Status In Use
Significance Moderate Significance
Documentation Date 8/10/2013; 2/26/2017

In 1870, the Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Minnesota Railway (BCR&M) began construction on a new railroad line, constructing 41 miles from Burlington, Iowa north to Columbus Junction, Iowa.  The following year, the railroad was completed an additional 116 miles through Cedar Rapids, Iowa to Waterloo, Iowa.  In 1872, an additional 64 miles was completed to Plymouth, Iowa.  Work on the line resumed in 1877, when the Burlington, Cedar Rapids & Northern Railway (BCR&N) completed an additional 5 miles to Manly, Iowa.  In 1878, the BCR&M became part of the BCR&N, completing a diagonal mainline from far southeast Iowa to north central Iowa.  By the 1880s, the BCR&N had become an important railroad in Iowa, connecting towns and cities in southeast Iowa to northern Iowa.  This line formed the principal mainline of the company, allowing for the construction of many additional branch lines.   By the turn of the 20th Century, the BCR&N operated over 1,000 miles of track throughout Iowa, connecting both small towns and large cities.  This line also served the basis of a northern extension to St. Paul, Minnesota; which was constructed between 1900 and 1901.  In June 1903, the BCR&N was acquired by the Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railway (Rock Island), which operated a large railroad network through the central United States. By acquiring the BCR&N, the Rock Island greatly expanded its service area, reaching major hubs such as St. Paul and Sioux Falls, South Dakota.

The Rock Island struggled financially throughout much of its history, experiencing repeated bankruptcies and chronic instability.  After World War II, the Rock Island struggled to survive, proposing mergers and deferring maintenance on their routes. The railroad reorganized as the Chicago, Rock Island & Pacific Railroad in 1948.  Despite the financial troubles, the Rock Island continued to use this route as a mainline, connecting to major agricultural areas in northern Iowa.  By the mid-1970s, the railroad was in serious decline.  The railroad secured loans to eliminate slow orders, acquired new equipment, and attempted to restore profitability.  In 1978, the railroad came close to profit, but creditors were lobbying for a complete shutdown of the Rock Island.  During the fall of 1979, a strike crippled the railroad, and by January of 1980, the entire system was ordered to be shut down and liquidated.  Many of the lines and equipment were scrapped.  Profitable sections of railroad were prepared for sale.  In 1981, a group of grain elevators along the route formed a short line railroad to operate over the bankrupt line.

In 1981 and 1982, the railroad was rehabilitated for use, and the route reopened for service.  In 1984, the Iowa Northern Railway (IANR) purchased the line.  A derailment near Burlington in 1985 caused the abandonment of much of the line south of Cedar Rapids, with only a small segment at Columbus Junction being sold to the Soo Line, which was controlled by Canadian Pacific Railway (CP) that year.  In the late 20th Century, the IANR became a profitable railroad, serving a variety of agricultural industries between Cedar Rapids and Manly.  A short segment of the line in Waterloo was abandoned in 1988, as the IANR had acquired trackage rights on a different line.  In 1994, IANR was sold to Iron Road Railways (IRR), a holding company. In 1997, CP would sell the line segment to I&M Rail Link, which was later purchased by the Dakota, Minnesota & Eastern Railroad (DM&E) subsidiary Iowa, Chicago & Eastern Railroad (IC&E).  After the bankruptcy of the IRR in 2003, the IANR was purchased by a former director of IRR, and grew considerably into a significant regional railroad.  

The DM&E/IC&E were purchased by Canadian Pacific in 2008, and the line at Columbus Junction abandoned shortly after due to a bridge collapse during the 2008 floods.  In 2025, the IANR was purchased by Canadian National Railway (CN), which already operated a significant railroad network in northern Iowa.  This was considered a somewhat unusual example of a large class-one railroad purchasing a short line with the intention of further growing business.  At the time of purchase, the IANR not only owned the Cedar Rapids to Manly mainline, but also operated branch lines to Oelwein and Forest City.  Today, CN operates the Cedar Rapids Subdivision between Cedar Rapids and Waterloo; and the Manly Subdivision between Waterloo and Manly.  South of Cedar Rapids, portions of the line have become part of the Hoover Nature Trail, while other sections are outright abandoned.  


Located southeast of Vinton, this massive concrete encased stone arch bridge carries a former Chicago, Rock Island & Pascific Railroad (Rock Island) mainline over Mud Creek and 13th Street. This location had long been a troublesome spot for the BCR&N, an issue which would not be fixed until the construction of the present bridge in the late 1890s. The first bridge at this location was likely a timber pile trestle bridge, constructed when the line was first built. In 1874, a 75-foot combination Howe deck truss span was installed on stone abutments to replace the first bridge, which had been damaged by flooding. This bridge was fabricated by an unknown Chicago firm, and was reportedly erected by railroad company. In 1884, the bridge was replaced by a 115-foot combination Howe through truss span, set onto new stone substructures and constructed slightly higher than the previous bridge. The 1874-era bridge was reportedly reused to cross Trout Run at Decorah, Iowa. It is believed that this bridge was replaced by an all-iron deck truss span in the late 1880s or early 1890s. The main issue with the line southeast of Vinton was a large "sag" in the railroad, which severely hindered operations. During the 1890s, a number of important upgrades were made to this line. One of the most significant upgrades was the reconstruction of approximately one mile of railroad to reduce grades and construct a larger bridge at Mud Creek. Work on the project was began in early 1898, and was completed that fall. As part of the work, a large double stone arch bridge was constructed, and the "sag" was largely filled. Upon completion, the stone arch bridge was heralded as one of the finest bridges in Iowa and a signature piece of infrastructure for the BCR&N. For an unknown reason, the bridge was significantly altered in approximately 1940, when a thick concrete encasement was added to almost the entire structure, giving the bridge its present appearance.

Currently, the bridge consists of a pair of 46-foot concrete encased stone arch spans, set onto concrete encased stone substructures and constructed for a single track at a width of 36 feet. The main spans follow a standard design, with semicircular arches and standard sized headwalls. Initially, the arch lines were constructed with high quality cut stone, and alternating stones at the top of the headwall were offset to create an accent. The arches are built directly onto the center pier, which originally had an angled upstream nose. Both abutments use stepped wing walls, which extended diagonally from the structure and have an offset top row of stones. After the c. 1940 encasement, a pipe railing was added to the bridge and all stone except for the wing walls was encased with concrete. The angled upstream nose was altered into a rounded upstream nose, while all stone features of the superstructure were entirely encased. Stone for the bridge consists of cut limestone, quarried at Cedar Valley, Iowa. Elmer J.C. Bealer had the contract to supply the stone and construct the bridge, while it is unclear if the concrete alterations were made by railroad company forces or by an unknown contractor. E.J.C. Bealer was a prominent late-19th Century stonemason, contractor and quarry manager based at the Cedar Valley Quarries at Cedar Valley, Iowa. E.J.C. Bealer served as both a stone supplier and as a contractor for several BCR&N bridges. Stone arches were popular for railroad use, as they were durable and easy to construct. Encasing stone arches in concrete was a popular 20th Century method to preserve and lengthen the life of stone bridges. Since the c. 1940 alterations, the bridge has seen no significant alterations. Today, it remains in use as part of a Canadian National Railway secondary line. Overall, the bridge appears to be in fair condition, with some spalling and cracking noted throughout the concrete encasement. Ironically, the exposed stone portions of the bridge appear to be in the best condition. The author has ranked this bridge as being moderately significant, due to the major alterations to the original structure. If the original stone arches were still visible, this structure would have been ranked higher. While many local newspapers promoted improvements in their communities as world-class, this structure lives up to the hype. The 46-foot arches are likely the largest stone arch spans in the State of Iowa, and are among the largest constructed for railroad use in the Midwest.


Citations

Builder and build date The Vinton Review; July 28, 1898
Railroad History Citation ICC Valuation Information, Compiled by Richard S. Steele

Loading...